Book Review Archives | Human Rights Careers http://www.humanrightscareers.com/tag/book-review/ Opportunities, Courses, Jobs, Internships Wed, 10 Nov 2021 23:32:40 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://www.humanrightscareers.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/cropped-stencil.twitter-profile-picture-modified-32x32.jpg Book Review Archives | Human Rights Careers http://www.humanrightscareers.com/tag/book-review/ 32 32 Book Review | Half the Sky: Turning Oppression into Opportunity for Women Worldwide https://www.humanrightscareers.com/magazine/book-review-half-the-sky-turning-oppression-into-opportunity-for-women-worldwide/ Sat, 25 Nov 2017 17:18:28 +0000 https://www.humanrightscareers.com/?p=6273 The post Book Review | Half the Sky: Turning Oppression into Opportunity for Women Worldwide appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

“Half the Sky: Turning Oppression into Opportunity for Women Worldwide” is a fierce book. It demands the world to address what the authors label “our era’s most pervasive human rights violation: the oppression of women and girls in the developing world”. The book is named after an ancient Chinese proverb – that women hold up […]

The post Book Review | Half the Sky: Turning Oppression into Opportunity for Women Worldwide appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

]]>
The post Book Review | Half the Sky: Turning Oppression into Opportunity for Women Worldwide appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

“Half the Sky: Turning Oppression into Opportunity for Women Worldwide” is a fierce book. It demands the world to address what the authors label “our era’s most pervasive human rights violation: the oppression of women and girls in the developing world”.

The book is named after an ancient Chinese proverb – that women hold up half the sky.

The authors Nicholas Kristof and Sheryl WuDunn are both Pulitzer Prize-winning journalists who through this amazing book meet extraordinary women across Asia and Africa. Among them is a Cambodian teenager sold into sex slavery and an Ethiopian woman who suffered devastating injuries in childbirth. Dalit women, Indian untouchables, who swarmed, stabbed and emasculated a serial torturer and murderer — in a courtroom. Further north, Mukhtar Mai, the victim of a Pakistani gang-rape, did the unthinkable for a Muslim village woman.

The book explores the many ways women and girls are mistreated across the world, including honor killings, prostitution, childbirth mortality rates, and unequal access to education and financial success.

Kristof and WuDunn believe that the oppression of women is our greatest moral challenge. “Half the Sky” tackles atrocities and indignities from sex trafficking to maternal mortality, from obstetric fistulas to acid attacks, and absorbing the fusillade of horrors can feel like an assault of its own. But the poignant portraits of survivors humanize the issues, divulging facts that moral outrage might otherwise eclipse.

Speaking to the Guardian, WuDunn shared “When you hear that 60 to 100 million females are missing in the current population, we thought that number compares in the scope and size. And then you compare the slave trade at its peak in the 1780s, when there were 80,000 slaves transported from Africa to the New World, and you see there are now 10 times that amount of women trafficked across international borders, so you start to think you are talking about comparable weight.”

Written with honesty, anger and truth, the authors take us on a journey to demonstrate how a little help can transform the lives of women and girls abroad. That Cambodian girl eventually escaped from her brothel and, with assistance from an aid group, built a thriving retail business that supports her family. The Ethiopian woman had her injuries repaired and in time became a surgeon.

The stories shared highlight the importance of gender equality in the fight against poverty. Women and girls hold so much untapped potential to truly transform communities and increase economic prosperity. As the Washington Post’s reviewer put it, this book is a “call to arms, a call for help, a call for contributions, but also a call for volunteers”.

The book concludes with Kristof and WuDunn noting that movements to improve women’s lives worldwide are most successful when they begin at a grassroots level, involving the women themselves, rather than paternalistic, Western interference. But, the authors note, there is much that readers can do to support the rights of women all over the world. First, we must stop thinking of rape and sex trafficking as women’s issues—they are human rights issues and impact everyone. Second, we can support organizations that work at the grassroots level with local women at the helm. Third, we must approach these issues like the civil rights issues they are. They are not less important than others because they primarily effect women, and should treated like the anti-slavery movements of the 19th century. Once we focus on maternal mortality, sexual violence, and human trafficking, we will effect true change.

The book has given birth to a whole global half the sky movement, which embraces different platforms and technologies to ignite the change needed to put an end to the oppression of women and girls worldwide. This global movement brings together video, websites, games, blogs, and other educational tools raise awareness and provide concrete steps to combat injustice, discrimination and empower women.

Half the Sky is essential reading for everyone, especially those concerned with changing the world and promoting human rights!

The post Book Review | Half the Sky: Turning Oppression into Opportunity for Women Worldwide appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

]]>
Book review: The Twilight of Human Rights Law by Eric A. Posner https://www.humanrightscareers.com/magazine/book-review-the-twilight-of-human-rights-law-by-eric-a-posner/ Sat, 11 Mar 2017 08:57:36 +0000 http://www.humanrightscareers.com/?p=4126 The post Book review: The Twilight of Human Rights Law by Eric A. Posner appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

Eric Posner in his book, The Twilight of Human Rights Law, seeks to explain why human rights law has failed. Eric Posner, a law professor at the University of Chicago, is skeptical of international law and applies a rationalist- realist approach to the questions of compliance (Antonov, 2016). He sets two objectives to be achieved […]

The post Book review: The Twilight of Human Rights Law by Eric A. Posner appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

]]>
The post Book review: The Twilight of Human Rights Law by Eric A. Posner appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

Eric Posner in his book, The Twilight of Human Rights Law, seeks to explain why human rights law has failed. Eric Posner, a law professor at the University of Chicago, is skeptical of international law and applies a rationalist- realist approach to the questions of compliance (Antonov, 2016). He sets two objectives to be achieved by the discussion in his book. First, he sought to provide the reader with a general introduction to human rights law. Second, he sought to demonstrate that human rights law has failed to accomplish its intentions and that the treaties on human rights do not increase the respect for the rights they contain.

Posner claims that human rights treaties carry a heavy burden that is rarely met in most occasions especially given the significance that was attached to them since the twentieth century. He brings out distinctly the main challenges facing the human rights law. He points out the wide gap between the proclamations made by people and the practices in the human rights law and identifies the various difficulties that arise from the multiplicity of rights (Hannum, 2015). These are the main challenges that face human rights and need to be addressed immediately if the efforts to reduce the gap and enforce compliance are to bear fruits.

The first three chapters of give a general outline of the international human rights law. Chapter one gives the history that begins with the pre-War intellectual rights-based foundations before it focuses on the post- War accounts of the United Nations system, the Cold War, and multiplicity of treaties on human rights. Chapter two discusses the existing formal human rights structures while describing prominent treaty regimes, mechanisms put in place by United Nations and the European regional system. In chapter three, Posner tackles the reason why states ratify the human rights treaties. He groups the states of the world into three: liberal-democratic, authoritarian and transitional. He states that there are different reasons why states enter into a treaty. Many states are mainly interest- driven and are motivated by the belief that a prominent treaty regime is too weak and therefore cannot influence the behavior of the acceding state.

The substantive arguments of influence Posner choice of introductory content to a great extent as reflected in the omission of alternative rights-based discourses that could lead to contradiction and less skepticism on the reasons as to why states would ratify human right treaties. He emphasizes the different interests that various states hold and how they appear to be in contravention of the commitments of formal rights and the extent to which multiplicity of the rights has led to great challenges in compliance. The extent to which these observations have succeeded in verifying Posner’s claim that human rights law has failed to achieve its objective is uncertain.

Posner further expounds that the failure of human rights law is mainly based on rule naiveté:  which postulates that the good in every state can be formulated into a set of rule which can be enforced uniformly. The ensuing failure of the human rights law to meet its objectives can be grouped into three categories: continuing violations despite the ratification of treaties, ambiguity and vagueness of the treaty, and conflicting values.

Posner guides his reader to evidence that illustrates an increase in the use of torture by the states that ratified the United Nation’s Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (Sethi, 2015). He asserts that such evidence should be able to change the perception of people who assume that the proliferation of human rights has led to an improvement of people’s by better enforcement of those rights.  His depictions of the wide gap between rhetoric and practice are also easily notable.

This book also provides an account of how various challenges continue to hinder the progress of the rights activists nationally and internationally. His conclusion that the human rights law has failed seems to have been arrived at hastily. The empirical support of his claims is not very strong as to challenge other studies that are contrary to his claims. He relies on a wide range of literature to support his claims on adherence and compliance to treaties. These assertions lack that persuasiveness that is depicted in the materials that demonstrate compliance with the international law.

The Twilight of Human Rights Law generally is not an essay on international legal theory. It is a critical commentary on the practice of human rights law and the limits Posner believes inherent to it. It ignites a great interest in the heart of a practitioner who wants to question the author’s view that the human rights law has been a failure and that ratification of treaties does not lead to an improvement in compliance and enforcement of those rights. In his endorsement of the book, Jack Goldsmith notes that Posner’s work will infuriate the human rights community. The key stakeholders in the human rights community are aware of the hypocrisy, the many existing wide gaps between compliance and the rhetoric, and the continuing violations despite the many treaties in existence. The main question raised by the book is whether efforts of the stakeholders are, as suggested by Posner, flawed and incomplete conclusion of the human rights project or merely a stage within it.

References

Antonov, M. (2016). The Twilight of Human Rights Law, written by Eric A. Posner. Review of Central and East European Law, 41(1), pp.49-53.

Hannum, H. (2015). The Twilight of Human Rights Law by Eric A. Posner. Human Rights Quarterly, 37(4), pp.1105-1109.

Sethi, S. (2015). United Nations’ Endeavors to Protect and Enhance Human Rights Around the World. A Reflective Essay and Review of Eric A. Posner, The Twilight of Human Rights Law. Journal of Business Ethics, 131(2), pp.505-507.

The post Book review: The Twilight of Human Rights Law by Eric A. Posner appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

]]>
5 Human Rights Books Everybody Should Read https://www.humanrightscareers.com/magazine/5-human-rights-books-everbody-should-read/ Sun, 18 Dec 2016 17:04:51 +0000 http://www.humanrightscareers.com/?p=3585 The post 5 Human Rights Books Everybody Should Read appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

Finding books on human rights topics is not difficult for those studying and working in this field. Finding relevant, challenging, and interesting books on human rights topics, however, is not always as easy. Books like Universal Human Rights in Theory and Practice by Jack Donnelly, The Tyranny of Experts by William Easterly, Development as Freedom […]

The post 5 Human Rights Books Everybody Should Read appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

]]>
The post 5 Human Rights Books Everybody Should Read appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

Finding books on human rights topics is not difficult for those studying and working in this field. Finding relevant, challenging, and interesting books on human rights topics, however, is not always as easy. Books like Universal Human Rights in Theory and Practice by Jack Donnelly, The Tyranny of Experts by William Easterly, Development as Freedom by Amartya Sen, Human Trafficking: Interdisciplinary Perspectives by Mary C. Burke, and Disposable People by Kevin Bales are all human rights texts that present unique perspectives and information while challenging readers to bring together knowledge and actions in effective ways. These books are useful adds to any human rights student’s or worker’s repertoire.

Jack Donnelly’s Universal Human Rights in Theory and Practice (3rd Ed., 2013) is a fundamental text for those studying any area of human rights. Starting out by establishing a basic understanding of what “human rights” means, Donnelly leads up to his main premise that human rights are equal, inalienable, and universal, even with cross-cultural relativism considerations. He ultimately argues that human rights are not culturally relative because culture is not the cause or a factor in the development of human rights ideas and practices and is not necessarily for or against any particular human rights. Donnelly states, “No particular culture or comprehensive doctrine is by nature either compatible or incompatible with human rights. It is a matter of what particular people and societies make of and do with their cultural resources. Cultures are immensely malleable…” (p. 107). Using a variety of examples from different countries, cultures, and points in history, Donnelly proceeds to provide examples that support his argument of universal rights versus cultural relativism. Much of his book centers around the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which has functioned as an authoritative body of rights, rooted in human dignity and universality, and agreed upon by most of the modern world, regardless of how they are actually played out in society. One major strength of this book is that Donnelly updates it to keep it relevant. While the first edition focuses a lot on Cold War-era examples and issues, the third edition focuses on issues of anti-genocide attitudes, the rights of sexual minorities, and the problems of poverty and political repression as consequences of development. Donnelly’s argument does get confusing and circular at times, if not dry, but even those who disagree with his premise will not deny that he offers a good foundation to human rights theories, as well as important ways to bridge the gap between theory and practice.

Visit Bookstore

Amartya Sen is an important author, economist, and philosopher for anyone in human rights work to know, and his book Development as Freedom (1999) is a perfect example of his expertise and deep understanding of human development and the importance of human rights. Sen argues that human freedom should be both the means and the end of development, rather than a casualty of it, as is often the case. He advocates for an integrated approach to development that involves multiple institutions and creates freedoms such as economic opportunities, political freedom, social supports, transparency from authorities, and security for society. Stating that development often forsakes freedoms and opportunities in the name of economic and human development, Sen argues that freedom must be central to development in order to create sustainable and effective change. He also addresses concerns and critiques surrounding the universal human rights discussion, including arguments about legality of human rights, duties involved in fulfilling rights, and questions about cultural relativism. In particular, Sen uses his own experiences from and expertise in Asian culture to argue that human rights and freedoms are not dependent upon cultural values or morality. He writes, “The case for basic freedoms and for the associated formulations in terms of rights rests on: 1) their intrinsic importance; 2) their consequential role in providing political incentives for economic security; 3) their constructive role in the genesis of values and priorities” (p. 246). Even through the extensive sidebar on Asian values, Sen tries to make this book accessible to a broad audience by avoiding jargon and technical terms, even encouraging readers to skip through certain theories and arguments, particularly those that contain major flaws. Development as Freedom is an important theoretical text for anyone studying or working in human rights, especially for those in the development field.

Visit Bookstore

For human rights professionals looking for a major ego check, William Easterly’s Tyranny of Experts (2013) provides just that. Though many are quick to disagree with his ultimate argument that human rights experts and development experts provide temporary solutions to deep problems and ultimately increase oppression of the poor, few can deny that his passionate writing and well-documented evidence make them second guess their work in the world. Coming off of a career at the World Bank, Easterly particularly critiques large international organizations and Western-based development ideals as the problem-causers because of their strategies for economic development in countries ruled by authoritarian dictators. He argues that development ideas primarily came about with a West-centric, discriminatory foundation: “Locating the formative years of development between 1919 and 1949 highlights a critical point: development ideas took shape before there was even the most minimal respect in the West for the rights of the individuals in the Rest” (p. 44). In particular, Easterly balks against the strategies of supporting authoritarian rulers and dictators in order to increase economies and reduce poverty. His argument is that the rights of the poor, particularly economic and political rights, are ultimately more important for their wellbeing and for their development than their material wellbeing. He states, “It doesn’t mean that we care less about the material suffering; it means that we understand that the autocrats have offered a false bargain to meet material needs while we overlook their suppression of rights” (p. 339). Easterly’s book offers a unique and challenging perspective for development and human rights workers, encouraging a change in the way we think about both human freedoms and human development.

Visit Bookstore

While Mary C. Burke is lesser known outside of the Pittsburgh area, her home base for work and research, her book Human Trafficking: Interdisciplinary Studies (2013), which is vetted by other major names in human trafficking research and books, is an essential resource for anyone researching or working with this specific human rights issue. Many human trafficking books offer chapters on various aspects of human trafficking, but Burke brings in established professionals for each of those fields to add personal experience and knowledge for the readers to gain, rather than relying on her research alone. From FBI agents to lawyers to psychologists, this book covers a wide-range of topics, all centered on how these areas intersect with the problem of human trafficking and how they impact the lives of victims of trafficking. While very obviously academic in genre (complete with learning objectives, discussion questions, and a “vocab” section specific to human trafficking), the book is a broad study of the topic, looking at both the problem from both a global perspective and a US-based perspective through case studies, laws and initiatives, and even a historical overview of slavery throughout society.

This book is certainly introductory in nature, but it provides a more in-depth, expertise look at the topic than other introductory books about human trafficking. One of the major foundations of this book in comparison to others like it is that it brings the issue close to home, with a section specifically focusing on community-level responses and initiatives, which as expert Judy Hale Reed writes, “have often been more effective at providing immediate responses of prevention and service provision to victims” (p. 256). Many of the authors have first-hand knowledge of this, having worked in the field with human trafficking, particularly in Burke’s home city of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The book keeps the topics concise and interesting to read, but these strengths also become its weaknesses in that the terminology and ideology behind human trafficking research is rapidly changing because of the newness of the topic and the growing literature surrounding it. In this instance, the case studies, stories, and first-hand examples offer more value than facts, figures, and definitions because they give a picture of the real problem, even in the midst of changing methodology, statistics, and estimates. Human Trafficking: Interdisciplinary Studies is a foundational text for human rights students who are specifically looking to focus on the topic of modern-day slavery.

Visit Bookstore

Kevin Bales’s Disposable People (2012) is a less academic-sounding text but contains useful and compelling information about modern-day slavery based on extensive research and experience. The book looks at specific stories from five different countries that all highlight a specific type of modern slavery. The book talks about many of the lesser mentioned types, including the antiquated slavery of Mauritania, forced labor that intersects environmental hazards in South America, and children working in brick kilns and brothels out of desperation for themselves and their families. The language in the book is emotional but supported by facts and research. The final chapter offers readers a relief to the heavy reading by providing ways to get involved and engage in the issue. The book also identifies various non-profits and international organizations that are working to help victims of various forms of trafficking. Bales own experience as co-founder of Free the Slaves contributes to both his passion and his knowledge of the subject.  Bales links America’s history with slavery to the current problem, telling a story of Frederick Douglass’s against Independence Day when slavery still existed. “If there are still slaves, how can you be proud of your freedom?” Bales concludes (p. 261). He encourages readers, “We can eradicate slavery. The laws are in place, international agencies like the UN are ready, but nothing will happen until the public demands action” (p. 262). Bales also provides credibility for his work by including an appendix with his research methodology and a second appendix with excerpts from international conventions against slavery. Of course, Disposable People is not an extensive study on these individual types of slavery, but it is an emotionally compelling and evidence-backed introductory text to any human rights student or professional interested in the topic of human trafficking.

Visit Bookstore

Whether focusing on a specific topic like human trafficking or looking for a general human rights overview, these five books present challenging and expert perspectives on their respective topics. For students, many of these books make regular appearances in human rights classes and will add important insight to other related literature. All of them would be useful for any student or professional looking to expand their knowledge and research on human rights topics.

Visit Bookstore

The post 5 Human Rights Books Everybody Should Read appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

]]>
Book review: Development as Freedom by Amartya Sen https://www.humanrightscareers.com/magazine/development-as-freedom-by-amartya-sen/ Tue, 16 Aug 2016 20:09:29 +0000 http://www.humanrightscareers.com/?p=1773 The post Book review: Development as Freedom by Amartya Sen appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

Amartya Sen is an important author, economist, and philosopher for anyone in human rights work to know, and his book Development as Freedom (1999) is a perfect example of his expertise and deep understanding of human development and the importance of human rights. Sen argues that human freedom should be both the means and the […]

The post Book review: Development as Freedom by Amartya Sen appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

]]>
The post Book review: Development as Freedom by Amartya Sen appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

Amartya Sen is an important author, economist, and philosopher for anyone in human rights work to know, and his book Development as Freedom (1999) is a perfect example of his expertise and deep understanding of human development and the importance of human rights. Sen argues that human freedom should be both the means and the end of development, rather than a casualty of it, as is often the case. He advocates for an integrated approach to development that involves multiple institutions and creates freedoms such as economic opportunities, political freedom, social supports, transparency from authorities, and security for society. Stating that development often forsakes freedoms and opportunities in the name of economic and human development, Sen argues that freedom must be central to development in order to create sustainable and effective change. He also addresses concerns and critiques surrounding the universal human rights discussion, including arguments about legality of human rights, duties involved in fulfilling rights, and questions about cultural relativism. In particular, Sen uses his own experiences from and expertise in Asian culture to argue that human rights and freedoms are not dependent upon cultural values or morality. He writes, “The case for basic freedoms and for the associated formulations in terms of rights rests on: 1) their intrinsic importance; 2) their consequential role in providing political incentives for economic security; 3) their constructive role in the genesis of values and priorities” (p. 246). Even through the extensive sidebar on Asian values, Sen tries to make this book accessible to a broad audience by avoiding jargon and technical terms, even encouraging readers to skip through certain theories and arguments, particularly those that contain major flaws. Development as Freedom is an important theoretical text for anyone studying or working in human rights, especially for those in the development field.

The post Book review: Development as Freedom by Amartya Sen appeared first on Human Rights Careers.

]]>